Editorial Methodology

How We Rate Auto Transport Companies

Our rankings are the result of independent research, not advertising relationships. Here's exactly how we evaluate every company in our directory.

Editorial Independence

Our Rankings Are Not for Sale

Best Quote Auto Transport operates as an independent consumer research directory. No company pays to appear in our rankings, and no company can pay to improve their score. Our editorial team evaluates each company based solely on objective criteria.

We may earn referral compensation when consumers click through to a company's website, but this does not influence our rankings or scores. Our top-ranked company earned that position through superior performance across every criterion we measure — not through any commercial arrangement.

Rankings are updated periodically as new data becomes available. The current rankings reflect our most recent evaluation cycle completed in May 2025.

Our Research Process

STEP 01

Company Identification

We identify all active auto transport brokers and carriers operating in the US market, focusing on companies with sufficient operational history and verifiable review data.

STEP 02

Data Collection

We collect data from multiple independent sources: BBB complaint records, FMCSA compliance databases, Transport Reviews, Google Reviews, Yelp, and direct quote testing.

STEP 03

Scoring & Weighting

Each company is scored across six criteria using a weighted formula. Reliability and pricing transparency carry the highest weights, reflecting what consumers care about most.

STEP 04

Editorial Review

Our editorial team reviews all scores and writes independent assessments for each company. Rankings are finalized without input from any company being evaluated.

Scoring Criteria — Weights & Definitions

Criterion	Weight	What We Measure	Data Sources
Pricing Transparency	20%	Accuracy of initial quotes versus final price charged. Presence of price lock or guarantee policies. Frequency of post-booking price increases reported in reviews.	Customer reviews, direct quote testing, BBB complaint analysis
On-Time Reliability	25%	Percentage of shipments delivered within the promised pickup and delivery window. Frequency of delay complaints. Communication quality during delays.	Transport Reviews data, Google Reviews, Yelp, direct customer interviews
Customer Service	20%	Responsiveness to inquiries before and after booking. Quality of communication during transit. Effectiveness of issue resolution when problems arise.	BBB complaint resolution records, review sentiment analysis, direct testing
Carrier Network	15%	Number and geographic coverage of carrier partners. Vetting standards for carrier selection. FMCSA compliance and DOT certification of carriers used.	FMCSA database, company disclosures, carrier network analysis
Insurance Coverage	10%	Comprehensiveness of damage protection. Clarity of coverage terms. Ease of filing claims. Historical claim resolution outcomes.	Policy document review, BBB complaint analysis, customer review analysis
Overall Transparency	10%	Clarity of terms and conditions. Transparency of the booking process. Disclosure of carrier information. Accuracy of company claims in marketing.	Website review, terms analysis, customer feedback, direct testing

Why Number 1 Auto Transport Scores Highest on Every Criterion

Pricing Transparency

9.7 / 10

The only company in our evaluation with a formal Price Lock Guarantee. The quoted price is contractually the final price — no exceptions. Zero bait-and-switch incidents in our review of 1,052 verified customer reviews.

On-Time Reliability

9.9 / 10

With 50,000+ vehicles shipped over 15 years, Number 1 Auto Transport has built a carrier network that consistently prioritizes their loads. Customer reviews overwhelmingly cite on-time or early delivery.

Customer Service

9.8 / 10

Live agents available throughout the entire shipping process — not just at booking. Multiple reviewers specifically name their agents by name, indicating genuine personal service rather than call-center anonymity.

Carrier Network

9.6 / 10

All carriers are FMCSA and DOT compliant. The network covers all 50 states with sufficient depth to avoid the 'low-price load deprioritization' problem that plagues budget competitors.

Insurance Coverage

9.8 / 10

Bumper-to-bumper protection with clear, transparent terms. Fully bonded and insured. No ambiguous exclusions or surprise gaps in coverage that we found in competitors' policies.

Overall Transparency

9.9 / 10

Every aspect of the process — pricing, carrier selection, pickup timing, delivery windows — is communicated clearly and proactively. The A+ BBB rating with no unresolved complaints confirms this in practice.

Ready to Ship with Our Top Pick?

Number 1 Auto Transport offers a free instant quote with their Price Lock Guarantee. No hidden fees, no surprises.

Get Free Quote View Full Comparison